IGN: Beyond its central conceit, the film doesn't have a lot of variations and there are definitely some moments in Tucker & Dale that lose steam. With the exception of the sweet portrayal of Allison, the group of college kids is not a very notable and interesting lot, beyond the one Total Douchebag dude who's the most gung-ho about going hillbilly hunting. And the film ends with a plot twist/reveal that seems pretty unnecessary.
Still, while it's not quite a home run, there's a lot to enjoy about Tucker & Dale vs. Evil. It's got its heart in the right place, and hey, it's just nice to root for the hillbillies for once in this scenario.