Jeremy of The Daily Rotation wrote, "You know you have a problem when a film manages to gather such an impressive cast of stars, but still comes out looking like a pile of shit. The Three Musketeers (2011) is very much a pile of shit and it’s an honest shame because the players are all here and the budget isn’t restraining much of the action from unfolding. The real problem is at the core of the production, director Paul W.S. Anderson, a man not known for making great movies, but for making okay movies. He’s made a career off of these subpar films and The Three Musketeers is no exception, despite its spot on casting for the four primary characters. The action is fun when it wants to be and messy when it shouldn’t be. The story makes little sense and logic is nowhere to be found!"