Jeremy of The Daily Rotation wrote, "This past summer has been known for the massive abundance of R rated comedies. Most were successful, like The Hangover Part II, Bad Teacher, Horrible Bosses and a few were not, like The Change-Up. But now with the fall coming in fast a few movies that might not have made the summer cut are getting some screen time. One of them is getting very limited screen time (currently at 143 theaters) and that is A Good Old Fashioned Orgy. I know what you’re thinking, that title sounds crazy and given some of the talent involved this one could either be insanely hilarious or incredibly dumb and I’m here to tell you it’s not either. A Good Old Fashioned Orgy is a funny movie and kind of a good movie, but it wasn’t nearly as raunchy or silly as the title suggests, instead it inserts enough jokes throughout the film to keep you laughing, but its main objective is actually the story. It’s a fun movie that I got a lot of enjoyment from, but it might come up as a disappointment for those expecting another insane R rated comedy like the ones I listed above."
CinemaBlend says:
The first trailer for the accurately titled comedy A Good Old Fashioned Orgy has arrived. Yep, it really is about an orgy.
The movie stars a stacked ensemble cast including the likes of Jason Sudeikis, Will Forte, Lake Bell, Lucy Punch, Martin Starr, Tyler Labine, Don Johnson, and Leslie Bibb in the story of a group of friends who decide to memorialize the end of their party days by doing the biggest thing imaginable: They’re throwing an orgy.
Sounds like what I expected, I want to see this!