I am indeed interested in seeing her in her first American film. Noomi that is.

I actually enjoyed it. This coming from something of a die hard Holmes fan as well. Granted it could've been more cerebral/thriller and a tad less Hollywood blockbuster/action. But I thought it was a fun movie and I liked their take on Holmes.

I'm real excited to see Moriarty and Mycroft.

I haven't watched the 1st one. But, I hope it isn't true about what you're saying. Because I love mystery type movies.

Yeah I've become a fan of his over the last couple years. He's really good at what he does.

i agree but it seems like he has been playing the same charcter in most of his movies lately. The quick comeback kinda thing. Its in sherlock in ironman etc.

I love Sherlock holmes im a huge Holmes fan and i love the movie but agree with the above it was more blockbuster then i expected but still i thought it was good. i cant wait for the Professor

Sometimes I prefer a simple number instead of some lame subtitle but in this case I agree. The subtitle is much more suiting than a "2".

I'm not really a fan of McAdams either... she has this huge following yet she's never done anything that impressed me.

I can do without Knightley too. I won't miss her at all in the new Pirates films.

I didn't mind McAdams in Sherlock. I don't think they did the Irene Adler character exactly right, but that's more on the writing and not McAdams. I don't love her, but I don't mind her at all. I enjoyed her in The Family Stone and she did perfectly fine in this and The Wedding Crashers.

As for Knightley: I enjoy her well enough too. She does have little things that makes her annoy me at times. But overall she's perfectly fine by me. I enjoyed her well enough in the Pirates movies (I'm not heartbroken she won't be back though in the sense that I don't think it will ruin the movie that she's not in it like some think). I loved her in Domino.