He keeps picking bad leads for these films, heck the only actor I've really liked in both films is Michael Fassbender.

it felt sloppy to me and kind of boring. I didn't care for any character and felt the acting was subpar... maybe the exception being Michael Fassbender.

I quite liked it as a disposable flick. Not so great fit in the series though. It suffers the same problems as many movies of this type, the characters involved seem to be unbelievably retarded.

Which is why the terrible (and totally predictable) ending was difficult to stomach.

SPOILERS

Would I divert from the (no doubt) well scouted mission? Probably not. We're colonists, not explorers, although I do see the motivation in this decision.
Would I fly right down to an unknown planet and wander around unprotected without knowing the first thing about the environment? Not a chance.
Would I open quarantine to try and shoot an alien I just saw kill a crew member? Haha. No. Because I'm not retarded.
Would I trust David? Not even as far as I could throw him, especially after I saw him cooing over the damn alien that just murdered your crew mate and crying about it when I shot it. I wouldn't take my gun off him.
Would I trust that my android won the fight I witnessed and not question it as soon as I was back on board the ship? Nope.

And so forth....

Total shit

Nope its awful, the script was jotted on a napkin awful. Promotheus was far superior.

I still really want to see this even though people hate it. I'll take anything I can when it comes to Alien/Prometheus canon