IGN:
The news that Pirates of the Caribbean 5 might be in development isn't exactly surprising. Though last year's On Stranger Tides didn't exactly bedazzle critics, it made a heaping helping of money for Disney. A fifth movie seems like a foregone conclusion.
I want something that isn't disappointing. I loved the first 3 films, but couldn't stand On Stranger Tides. I'd rather them just stop than eventually ruin the franchise.
I didn't care for Penelope Cruz in that last one. The story was just so so. I would like to see maybe Will Turner's son as a young pirate in the next one. I think that would make for some fun with Jack Sparrow.
I liked that the last one kinda hinted at the original. The original is easily one of my top films, but the next two were kinda slow and hard to watch a second time.
I just want something more action packed, humorous, and still has a rich story like the original. Pretend like you need to launch the franchise again and try hard to do it.