Sam Fragoso wrote:
"Think Like A Man is imperfect, as is any human relationship, but the film manages to find laughter and warmth, in spite of its narrative obstacles. Most conversations between the characters deal with the concept of a relationship. While it may not having anything new or refreshing to say about the act of falling in and out of love, there’s a lively spirit that Tim Story captures that I can’t quite identify. Perhaps that’s a good thing though."