IGN - If Cowboys & Aliens worked for you, great! A lot of effort went into the film, and I hope it finds an audience that adores it. That audience just won't include me. The disc is certainly dynamite, with great extras, a solid transfer and a demo-worthy DTS-HD track. Buy this one only if you love the movie. But I'd advise others to rent it first before buying. Or just skip the film altogether and check out the remakes of 3:10 to Yuma and True Grit instead.