Jeremy of The Daily Rotation wrote, "Visually, Immortals is a perfect companion piece to sit next to Zack Snyder‘s 300. Where 300 resembles the graphic novel with washed out grays and heavy grain and filtering, Immortals looks polished, clear and almost fake. Backdrops look painted, characters stick out with gold colored armor and orange skin and each location varies heavily from the last. Immortals is a visual treat thanks to director Tarsem Singh and his particular eye for painting a story. He makes it feel like its own film, not trying to copy any other popular films of the genre, instead trying to sit rightfully beside them. Unfortunately for Immortals that is its highest praise. The visuals are worthy of the dimming 3D and the blood and violence is sure to please fans of war, but the story takes more time than it needs to establish, making the film at times feel like more of a task to watch."