Everything he's done but Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction is garbage? Really? I loved Kill Bill. And I thought Inglorious Basterds was a real good movie. I also like Four Rooms (though he only directed one of the rooms). Death Proof I enjoyed as well in that b-movie sort of way.

Ultimately, I've enjoyed everything he's directed. Granted Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction are my favorites, but I don't at all think the rest is garbage.

Oh JL - I thought you and I had a good movie thing going pal. Inglorious Basterds was a huge disappointment for me. I expected so much more and felt kinda ripped off at the end of the day. Kill Bill was total crap. I don't see what he sees in Uma Thurman but he's gotta get away from casting her in movies. Kill Bill was turned off within 10 minutes in my house because I was so insanely annoyed by it. Death Proof was OK - but it still failed to deliver anything other than some half decent skitch acting and effects. I found Planet Terror to be a far superior movie in every aspect.

and why the hell can't I reply directly to your comment JL?

lol Oh well, Crazay. All tastes/preferences must diverge somewhere. We all have those things that, for whatever reason, appeal to us. Thus, we're all entitled to our opinion. No matter how similar two people are in taste for movies, there's going to be some area they disagree. I guess Quentin seems to be our dividing wall lol

I'm sure we'll find plenty more common ground in the future though :)

Oh, and why you can't direct reply to my comment? Because it's too deep in. The comment system only goes 3 branches deep. Dark made the first comment. You replied to his making a 2nd tier. I replied to yours making a 3rd tier. And that 3rd tier is where it's set to stop. They did it that way just so things don't get out of hand with a million different indented tiers of replies (mostly due to the way they like to comment on N4G).

Its not a musical movie, I hate those. Its Disney showing off they can still do what made them Disney and thats why i love it. It had the entire Disney formula in it and had that magic feel to it. Something Disney hasn't done in years.

I've been told by so many people that it was a musical. One of my friends who loves Disney said it wasn't too dissimilar to the style of Beauty and the Beast so that immediately soured me on the idea of watching that.

Maybe not your traditional full-out musical, but pretty much all Disney movies essentially are musicals. Or at least in the very same ballpark. They're pretty much the only "musicals" I like.