Never Seen It highlights films that you might not have heard of or watched but definitely should, the kind of films that aren’t as well-known as others and don’t attain the accreditation or accolade they perhaps deserve. The films noted may not be 5-star features but every one mentioned is a film worthy of your time…
You want some real examples, try:
Old Boy
Run Lola Run
The Day Watch trilogy (though unfortunately the third hasn't made it to film yet)
Requiem for a Dream
Pi
Donnie Darko
Audition
Dark City (the original Matrix)
Want to stick to just comedies that aren't necessarily 5-star movies but worth the watch?
Idle Hands
BASEketball
The Gods Must Be Crazy
My Super Ex-Girlfriend
The Man Who Knew Too Little
Grosse Point Blank
Beerfest
Ghost Town
A Goofy Movie
Balls Out
Bandits
Drop Dead Fred
Shaun of the Dead
Hot Fuzz
The Good Girl
The Onion Movie
I Hope They Serve Beer in Hell
Film Geek
Grandma's Boy
That's just to name a few.
One I'd like to mention as well, I think technically it's a "horror" movie. But it's a mockumentary and can be pretty funny in parts. Behind the Mask: The Rise of Leslie Vernon.