AVClub: The Night Of never quite decided what it wanted to be. There’s the part of this show that aimed for verisimilitude, that eschewed normal crime show beats to show how the various aspects of the criminal justice system work. Then there was the part that felt like something more traditional, with the kinds of clever themes and dramatic plot twists that, while potentially worthwhile on their own merit, clashed with the show’s more naturalistic aspects. Sometimes, The Night Of found ways to play around with that tension. Take Box’s subplot tonight.