It should of happened at the Prison last season, since Judith is still alive.

Rick should of walked over to see Judith's empty basket and Carl next to it shot. They would of had an emotional goodbye while he dies in Ricks arms. The Walkers get closer and it looks like Rick is about to give up until Carol appears, she shoots some of them, pulls Rick away and they leave together.

They are straying away from the comics so I don't know why they won't kill him off, it would be such big character development for Rick and it would be getting rid of a character nobody likes. It would still be shock value since most of us doubt he would get killed off anyway.

I mean if Darryl got offed over Carl I would be so ticked off.

Oh did you, my mistake I thought you meant Carl

They would of had to change it but thats what I meant....they should of changed it around

So later on Carol would of met up with Tyrese who has Judith much to Ricks surprised and the incident with the two girls would of happened....just Rick would of been there instead...maybe Michone would of met up with them.

"Personally, I think it's high time to lose the baby"

I agree, I only wanted her around if they decided to kill Carl off instead, something to give Rick hope and to protect but since that isn't happening they should get rid of her

They should of got Lori shot the same way in the comics but had Carl in Judiths place and then Judiths death would of happened off screen like the empty bloody basket.