410°
Submitted by darklordzor 375d ago | opinion piece

8 Movies Which Are Better Than the Books They're Based On

From Cinelinx:

Just about every movie buff has heard this phrase uttered (if they didn’t say it themselves) by someone, “The movie was good...but the book was better.” Since books have significantly more time to cover character development and a deeper story, there are many people who think this is always the case. Because of that, I’ve come up with a list of the 6 movies that were actually better than the books...Just so you have something to come back with in these kinds of discussions. (Culture)

hazelamy  +   375d ago
i'd say Children Of Men.

the book is more about the government trying to control the populace rather than humanity trying to come to terms with the knowledge of it's impending extinction.

and the lead character of Theo really isn't very likeable in the book, he only seems to agree to help the pregnant girl because he has an attraction to her.

whereas the character in the film seems a little more altruistic, not an out and out hero, he's still got his own reasons, but they're less creepy.

and Clive Owen puts in a fantastic performance in the role.
makes me kinda sad we'll probably never get to see what he could have done with the role of James Bond.

oh and Michael Caine is fantastic as an ageing hippy.

the way the film captures the hopelessness of the situation is just brilliant.

i definitely enjoyed the film more than the book.
rhcpfan  +   374d ago
Requiem for a Dream
gigoran  +   374d ago
As soon as I saw the title "congo" the article lost any credibility it may have had. Comparing congo to the original book is like comparing one piece of feces to another. Even if one is browner than the other, in the end they are both still pieces of excrement. that exact same comparison could be said for twilight. And as for a clockwork orange and fight club... look if the intentions of the writer were to drive up controversy and have people complain and disagree with him, he may very well succeed.
darklordzor  +   373d ago
It's not about controversy at all. I'm not saying either of those books are bad, I'm simply saying the films worked out better, and for those two in particular the reason is because the films made it easier for a wider audience to accept the same message. Reaching people who would be totally lost when they tried to read the book.

As for Congo, I never said either the book or film were very good. In fact I make it known, that neither are "great" by any means. But the film is better than the book, which is the point.

Perhaps reading an article all the way through is in order...
RetrospectRealm  +   374d ago
Most of these are kind of totally obvious while the others are just not true at all.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Stan Lee Discusses His Big Hero 6 Cameo In New Video

2h ago - CBM: We have two new videos for Big Hero 6, one of which is a featurette with Stan Lee himself in... | Cinema
20°

Rosario Dawson Tells Us Everything She Possibly Can About ‘Daredevil’

22h ago - MTV Marvel is infamous for shrouding its projects in secrecy — all the better for a dramatic u... | VOD

Guggenheim "Flash" Crossover Changed His Mind On Superpowers On "Arrow"

22h ago - CBR: Earlier this fall at the start of "Arrow" season three, series executive producer Marc Gugge... | TV
10°

Newest DC All Access Episode Features New Constantine Footage

22h ago - CBM: Hit the jump to check out some new footage for NBC’s Constantine provided Tiffany, the host... | TV
Ad

Win a ROKU 3 or AMAZON FIRE TV

Now - Find out how you can win your choice of a Roku 3 or an Amazon Fire TV on Filmwatch. | Promoted post

Arrow Scoop: Sin Returns for 'Pivotal' Role in Sara Murder Mystery

22h ago - TVLine Though Sin was conspicuously absent from the immediate aftermath of BFF Sara’s murder,... | TV