Clickonline writes: "The real problem with To the Wonder is that it isn’t really about anything. Malick is not a filmmaker who hits audiences over the head with his meaning but by the time 20 minutes had passed without a single word uttered between characters, it was clear to me that this was on another level entirely."
Entertainment Fuse writes, "The rhythm and pace of the movie ebbs and flows in accordance with the protagonist’s relationship. There are many moments of joy and bliss, but they are accompanied by disappointment and disillusionment. There is longing but an equal amount of inability to attain one’s desires."
Independent Cinema writes: With 2011′s The Tree of Life, I was completely confused by the positive reception it had received. It felt like a Terrence Malick film, designed only for Terrence Malick to enjoy. With To The Wonder, nothing has changed, except that Malick has eradicated any interesting ideas from his previous film and boiled it down to one over-arching theme: love. How does that love manifest itself? Where can we find it? Is it guaranteed that we will find it? Unfortunately for To The Wonder, it is too broad of a topic and most of the characters are not developed enough to truly appreciate their situations. Because of this lack of development, the film ultimately becomes a series of beautifully shot scenes, that are just as enigmatic and ambiguous as love itself.
Jeremy of The Daily Rotation wrote, "Visionary director Terrence Malick returns just two short years after The Tree of Life to tell another grand story, only this time focusing on relationships, love and the meaning of forgiveness. To the Wonder has been said to be Malick’s “Tree of Love” reaction to The Tree of Life, but aside from his trademark visuals, the film is much more distant and empty. To the Wonder is Malick’s weakest effort yet, blending together middling performances with beautiful locations. The film never quite adds up to anything more than a Malick demo reel of footage."
There are those who will get it and there will be those who won't. There are bigger ideas here, bigger questions to ask, more beauty and mystery if you just remove yourself from your preconceptions and how a movie "should be". Look closely and you will find meaning and purpose behind To The Wonder and it is a profound one. The same with The Tree of Life. A certain maturity and spiritual awareness is needed when watching a Malick film. Open your eyes and ears and experience the wonders of life.
